Research · Dental implants

Do I need a bone graft or a sinus lift before implants, and how well do they work?

14 min read · Based on 15 studies

The short answer

Only if your 3D scan shows too little bone where the implant has to go. When a graft is needed, the results are reassuring: implants placed with a graft did about as well as other implants in a large national dataset, and most implants placed after a sinus lift were still in place 5 to 13 years later 1, 15. A graft can add healing months and can change when you fly home, but it fits into the usual two trips. The treating dentist decides, case by case.

Then he explains it to the patient: the state of the bone, the state of the teeth, whether bone grafting is needed, what the process is, and he answers their questions.

Hudson Nguyen, Founder
  • A graft is needed only when the 3D scan shows too little bone in height or width. The scan, not the price list, decides.
  • Implants in grafted bone last well: 97.83% success with a graft placed at the same time in one national dataset, and 95.8% pooled survival after an open sinus lift 1, 15.
  • In some thin upper jaws, a short implant can replace a sinus lift, with similar implant failure in randomised trials and fewer complications 3, 4, 5, 6.
  • The two ways of doing a sinus lift, through the implant hole or through a side window, showed no clear difference in implant failure, and the hole method caused less discomfort 11, 12.
  • Smoking and very thin bone under the sinus lower the odds, and grafts carry their own complications, from sinus lining tears to infection 1, 8, 13.
  • A graft fits into the usual two trips to Vietnam, with no trip added. It can lengthen the healing gap, and a sinus lift changes when you can fly home.

What a bone graft and a sinus lift are

An implant is a small titanium screw that needs bone all the way around it, the way a screw needs solid wood. After a tooth comes out, the bone that held it slowly shrinks. Gum disease and years of wearing a denture can shrink it further.

A bone graft adds bone where there is too little. The material is usually a processed bone substitute, sometimes mixed with a little of your own bone. Over the following months your body grows new bone into it.

A sinus lift is a bone graft in one particular place. Above your upper back teeth sits the maxillary sinus, an air space inside the cheekbone. When the bone under it is thin, the dentist lifts the sinus lining a few millimetres and places graft material underneath. A normal implant then has room to sit.

These are the common kinds of graft, from smallest to largest.

  • Socket graft: graft material placed in the hole left by a pulled tooth, to slow the shrinking.
  • Guided bone regeneration, often called GBR: graft material and a thin cover called a membrane, placed beside the implant to fill a gap or widen the bone.
  • Closed sinus lift: the lining is lifted through the same small hole drilled for the implant. Dentists also call it transcrestal or crestal.
  • Open sinus lift: the lining is lifted through a small window in the side of the jaw, for thinner bone. Dentists call it a lateral window lift.
  • Block graft: a solid piece of bone fixed to the jaw with small screws, for larger losses.

Most grafts are done under local anaesthetic in the dental chair, often in the same appointment as the implant.

Do you need one? What the scan decides

The 3D scan shows how tall and how wide the bone is where each implant will go. In the upper back jaw it also shows how much bone sits under the sinus. Dentists call that height the residual bone height.

That height shapes the plan. A large review found that implant survival after a sinus lift dropped when less than 4 mm of bone remained under the sinus 1. The randomised trials on short implants studied upper jaws with 4 to 9 mm of bone left 3.

Your situation and the usual choice
Your situationUsual choiceWhy
Enough bone in height and widthImplant only, no graftNothing to add. Most single implants fall here.
A small gap beside the implant, or a thin wall of boneImplant with GBR in the same surgeryImplants with a graft placed at the same time did about as well as other implants in a national dataset 15.
A tooth being pulled where an implant will go laterSocket graft at the extraction, in some casesIt slows the shrinking of the bone while the gum heals. The dentist decides.
Upper back jaw, bone under the sinus a little shortClosed sinus lift, or a short implantBoth are smaller surgery than an open lift. Short implants of 6 mm showed similar 5-year survival to a sinus lift in trials 5.
Upper back jaw, very little bone under the sinusOpen sinus lift, with the implant the same day or laterSurvival is lower when under 4 mm of bone is left, so more bone has to be built first 1.
Bone lost in height along the ridgeVertical augmentation: GBR or a block graftThe most demanding grafts, with the highest complication rates 14.
A whole upper jaw with little boneAngled implants such as All-on-4, a graft, or bothAngled implants can use the bone that is there. The dentist weighs this against grafting.

A flat X-ray can make the bone look taller than it is. That is one reason the graft decision is made from the 3D scan, and why it is sometimes confirmed only once the gum is open on the day.

How well implants in grafted bone do

This is the good news, and it rests on large numbers.

A national dataset covered 158,824 implants, including 45,715 with a bone graft placed at the same time 15. The grafted group had a success rate of 97.83%, comparable to implants without a graft 15.

For sinus lifts, a 2026 review pooled 32 studies and 7,902 implants followed for 5 to 13 years 1. Pooled long-term survival was 95.8% 1. Most of the failures happened in the first three years of use 1.

97.83%success for implants placed with a graft, across 45,715 grafted implants in one national dataset 15.

0.43%a year: the weighted annual implant loss after a sinus lift, in prospective studies of at least 5 years 2.

The main studies on implants in grafted bone
StudyWhat it coveredWhat it found
Findler 2026 15158,824 implants in one national healthcare network, 45,715 with a graft 1597.83% success with a graft, comparable to other implants 15
Sabri 2026 132 studies, 7,902 implants after an open sinus lift, 5 to 13 years 195.8% pooled survival 1. Graft material did better than no graft, and smoking and under 4 mm of bone did worse 1
Raghoebar 2019 211 prospective studies, at least 5 years, 6 mm of bone or less 20.43% implant loss a year 2. No difference between implants placed with the lift or later 2
Aghaloo 2016 740 studies of whole upper jaws with no teeth 7Weighted survival 91.5% after sinus lifts and 85.2% in block grafts on the ridge 7

Read the older full-jaw figures with care. The review covered studies from 1980 to 2014, and implants and grafting have changed since then 7.

Short implants: the option that can avoid a sinus lift

A short implant is shorter than a standard one, so it can fit into the bone that is already under the sinus. That can mean no sinus lift, a smaller surgery and a quicker plan.

  • A 2026 review of 8 randomised trials found no significant difference in implant failure between short implants and standard implants with a sinus lift 4.
  • A 2024 review of 19 randomised trials rated the evidence moderate to high that 6 mm implants in the upper jaw match a sinus lift at five years 5.
  • For 4 mm and 5 mm implants, the same review found the evidence still inconclusive 5.
  • The Cochrane review found more complications at sites that had a sinus lift 3.
  • A review of trials with at least 5 years of follow-up found fewer biological complications with short implants, and a slightly higher survival with a sinus lift that did not reach significance 6.

So a short implant is a real option, not a shortcut. It depends on how much bone is left, how strong it is and what the tooth has to carry, and the dentist decides from your scan.

Closed or open sinus lift

A 2026 review pooled 13 randomised trials that compared the two ways of lifting the sinus 11. It found no significant difference in implant failure, sinus lining tears, bone loss or bone gained 11. The certainty was low to very low, and the reviewers concluded that neither method has been shown to be better 11.

Patients felt a difference, though. A review of patient-reported outcomes found that closed lifts caused less discomfort than open ones 12. Lifts done without graft material also caused less pain at 3 and 7 days than lifts with graft 12.

The choice follows the bone. A closed lift suits bone that is a little short. An open lift suits bone that is very thin, because it lets the dentist see and place more graft.

What can go wrong, and how often

Grafts are routine, but they are surgery. These are the problems the reviews report.

Graft and sinus lift complications in the reviews
ProblemHow oftenWhat it means
A tear in the sinus lining during a liftBetween 7% and 56% of lifts 8The most common problem. When it was repaired, implant survival was 97.1% against 97.7% without a tear 8.
Sinus infection after an open lift3% to 5% in the literature 13It can be acute or long-lasting, and an ear, nose and throat doctor may be needed to treat it 13.
Complications after GBR to gain height16.80% of sites 14Gaining height is the most demanding kind of graft.
Complications after block grafts to gain height38.01% of sites 14The biggest grafts carry the most risk, which is one reason dentists avoid them where they can.
Implant loss after a sinus liftAbout 0.43% a year 2Most failures come in the first three years of use 1.

Two things you control lower the odds. Smoking significantly lowered implant survival after sinus lifts 1. Gum disease and uncontrolled diabetes also matter for any implant, so they are checked and treated first.

The evidence has gaps. Most long-term sinus lift data comes from records looked at afterwards rather than planned trials 1. Many short-implant trials are short, and the reviewers ask for longer ones 6. Treat the numbers as a guide to the odds, and ask the dentist what your own bone means for them.

Same day or in stages, and how long the bone needs

A graft can go in during the same surgery as the implant, or first, with the implant placed once the graft has healed. The dentist chooses from how firm the implant can be on the day.

  • Same day: possible when there is enough bone to hold the implant firmly while the graft heals around it. One surgery, one recovery.
  • In stages: used when the bone is too thin to hold the implant at first. The graft heals, then the implant goes in.
  • For sinus lifts, a long-term review found no significant difference in implant loss between the two orders 2.

Grafted bone takes months to mature. A small randomised trial compared healing periods of 4 and 8 months after sinus lifts in 14 people 10. The longer wait gave significantly more new bone and better-organised bone 10. The trial measured bone samples, not implant survival, so it shows why dentists give grafts time rather than setting a fixed number.

What a graft means for your trips to Vietnam

Implant treatment runs as two trips of about 7 days each, 3 to 6 months apart while the bone heals. A graft fits into those two trips, with no trip added. What it can change is the length of the gap and the timing of your flight home.

  1. 1 Before you flySend any recent scan or X-rays. The dentist can say early whether a graft is likely, so it is in your plan and your quote.
  2. 2 First tripThe 3D scan and the plan, then surgery: the implant, the graft, or both. Rest and checks follow in the same stay.
  3. 3 Healing at homeThe graft and the implant heal together. With a larger graft the dentist may ask for the longer end of the gap, or longer.
  4. 4 Second tripA check that the implant is firm, then the final teeth.

Flying after a sinus lift needs its own plan. Air pressure changes in the cabin can push on a healing sinus. A 2023 review of flying after dental work, written with dental travel in mind, suggests waiting at least 72 hours after implant placement 9. After a sinus lift it suggests at least two weeks and recommends six 9.

That review also says most of the research behind it comes from military aircrew, not commercial passengers 9. So it is a starting point, not a rule. If a sinus lift is likely in your case, settle the date of the flight home with the dentist before you book it. A closed lift is smaller surgery than an open one, and the dentist may judge the two differently.

After a sinus lift, agree the flight home with the dentist before you book it.

Clinics give a written aftercare sheet after a sinus lift. It usually asks you not to blow your nose hard, to sneeze with your mouth open, and to avoid straws and heavy lifting for the first days. Keep it with you on the flight and at home.

Grafts are charged only if your case needs them, and the graft prices are on our pricing page. Ask for any likely graft to be written into your quote before you fly, with the reason.

Common beliefs that are not quite right

  • "A graft means the implant is more likely to fail." In a national dataset, implants with a graft did about as well as other implants 15.
  • "Everyone needs a graft." Many implants go into the bone that is already there. The scan decides.
  • "A sinus lift is the only answer for thin upper bone." Short implants of 6 mm matched a sinus lift at five years in trials, for some jaws 5.
  • "An open lift is stronger than a closed one." Trials found no clear difference in implant failure, and the closed lift was more comfortable 11, 12.
  • "A graft adds a trip." It fits into the usual two trips. It can lengthen the healing gap.
  • "I can fly the day after a sinus lift." One review suggests at least two weeks 9.

Questions to ask the dentist before you book

Take these to the online meeting, while your dates can still move.

  • Does my scan show enough bone for the implant, in height and in width?
  • If I need a graft, will it go in during the same surgery as the implant, or first?
  • Is a short implant an option instead of a sinus lift in my case?
  • Will a sinus lift be closed or open, and why?
  • How long after the sinus lift can I fly home?
  • Does the graft change the gap between my two trips?
  • Is the graft written into my quote, with the reason?
  • What does normal healing feel like, and what should make me contact you?

What we at The Hudson decide, and what we do not

The Hudson plans and coordinates dental trips to Vietnam for people from Australia, New Zealand and the UK. We are not a clinic.

We do not decide whether you need a graft, which material is used or which sinus lift is done. The treating dentist at the partner clinic decides that case by case, from your 3D scan and the examination. The dentist can also change the plan during surgery if the bone is different from what the scan suggested.

Our part is practical. We pass your X-rays and notes to the clinic before you fly, keep the written plan and the quote in one place, and set your dates around the healing time and the flying advice the dentist gives. If the plan changes on the day, we tell you what changed and what it means for your trip.

The clinic pays us a referral fee for each patient. You pay us nothing.

Quick answers

Is a sinus lift the same as a bone graft?

It is one kind of bone graft. It adds bone under the sinus in the upper back jaw, so an implant has enough bone to sit in.

Can a short implant replace a sinus lift?

Sometimes. Reviews of randomised trials found similar implant failure for short implants and sinus lifts in some thin upper jaws 4, 5. It depends on how much bone you have, so the dentist decides. More on replacing a back molar.

Does a graft add a trip to Vietnam?

No. A graft fits into the usual two trips. It can lengthen the healing gap between them, and the dentist sets the timing.

Is a closed sinus lift easier than an open one?

For most people, yes. Closed lifts caused less discomfort than open ones, and trials found no clear difference in implant failure between the two 11, 12. Which one you need depends on how much bone is left.

Do implants in grafted bone last?

Most do. Implants with a graft did about as well as other implants in a national dataset, and pooled survival after sinus lifts was 95.8% at 5 to 13 years 1, 15. Smoking and very thin bone lower the odds 1.

Read next

Sources

  1. Sabri H, Saleh MHA, Nava P, et al. Long-term outcomes of lateral sinus floor elevation: A machine-learning analysis, systematic review, and meta-analysis of predictive factors. Periodontology 2000, 2026. Systematic review and meta-analysis. PubMed 41881515. DOI 10.1111/prd.70028.
  2. Raghoebar GM, Onclin P, Boven GC, et al. Long-term effectiveness of maxillary sinus floor augmentation: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of clinical periodontology, 2019. Systematic review and meta-analysis. PubMed 30624789. DOI 10.1111/jcpe.13055.
  3. Esposito M, Felice P, Worthington HV. Interventions for replacing missing teeth: augmentation procedures of the maxillary sinus. The Cochrane database of systematic reviews, 2014. Cochrane systematic review of randomised trials. PubMed 24825543. DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD008397.pub2.
  4. Wang C, Xin C, Zhang N, et al. Short implants (≤ 8 mm) versus standard implants with sinus floor elevation in the atrophic posterior maxilla: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Journal of stomatology, oral and maxillofacial surgery, 2026. Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. PubMed 42520929. DOI 10.1016/j.jormas.2026.102913.
  5. Ravidà A, Serroni M, Borgnakke WS, et al. Short (≤6 mm) compared with ≥10-mm dental implants in different clinical scenarios: A systematic review of randomized clinical trials with meta-analysis, trial sequential analysis and quality of evidence grading. Journal of clinical periodontology, 2024. Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. PubMed 38764386. DOI 10.1111/jcpe.13981.
  6. Mester A, Onisor F, Di Stasio D, et al. Short Implants versus Standard Implants and Sinus Floor Elevation in Atrophic Posterior Maxilla: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials with ≥5 Years' Follow-Up. Journal of personalized medicine, 2023. Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. PubMed 36836403. DOI 10.3390/jpm13020169.
  7. Aghaloo TL, Misch C, Lin GH, et al. Bone Augmentation of the Edentulous Maxilla for Implant Placement: A Systematic Review. The International journal of oral & maxillofacial implants, 2016. Systematic review. PubMed 27228250. DOI 10.11607/jomi.16suppl.g1.
  8. Schiavo-Di Flaviano V, Egido-Moreno S, González-Navarro B, et al. Influence of Schneiderian Membrane Perforation on Implant Survival Rate: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Journal of clinical medicine, 2024. Systematic review and meta-analysis. PubMed 38999315. DOI 10.3390/jcm13133751.
  9. Felkai PP, Nakdimon I, Felkai T, et al. Dental tourism and the risk of barotrauma and barodontalgia. British dental journal, 2023. Literature review. PubMed 36707585. DOI 10.1038/s41415-023-5449-x.
  10. Pasquini Filho R, Klüppel LE, Freitas RM, et al. Histological evaluation of bone graft healing in maxillary sinus floor augmentation at two healing time points: a randomized clinical trial. Brazilian dental journal, 2026. Small randomised split-mouth trial. PubMed 41637254. DOI 10.1590/0103-644020256560.
  11. Lee H, Lee SB, Kim NJ, et al. Crestal Versus Lateral Window Approaches for Maxillary Sinus Floor Augmentation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Medicina (Kaunas, Lithuania), 2026. Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. PubMed 42942504. DOI 10.3390/medicina62101973.
  12. Menini M, Canullo L, Pesce P, et al. Patient-Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) in Sinus Elevation Procedures: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. The International journal of oral & maxillofacial implants, 2026. Systematic review and meta-analysis of 12 studies. PubMed 40553622. DOI 10.11607/jomi.11434.
  13. Valentini P. How to Prevent and Manage Postoperative Complications in Maxillary Sinus Augmentation Using the Lateral Approach: A Review. The International journal of oral & maxillofacial implants, 2023. Narrative review. PubMed 37847842. DOI 10.11607/jomi.10145.
  14. Sáez-Alcaide LM, González Gallego B, Fernando Moreno J, et al. Complications associated with vertical bone augmentation techniques in implant dentistry: A systematic review of clinical studies published in the last ten years. Journal of stomatology, oral and maxillofacial surgery, 2023. Systematic review. PubMed 37499904. DOI 10.1016/j.jormas.2023.101574.
  15. Findler M, Doron H, Mann J, et al. Clinical Success Rates of Dental Implants with Bone Grafting in a Large-Scale National Dataset. Journal of functional biomaterials, 2026. Retrospective study of a national dataset. PubMed 41590814. DOI 10.3390/jfb17010046.

How we made this article: it is written from the studies listed above. Before it went live, every study was looked up, every quote matched to the study's abstract and every number checked against the study it comes from. Prices come only from our own price list. Hudson reads every article after it goes live, and the date it changed is shown at the top. This is general information, not advice for your own mouth: the dentist who examines you decides what is right for you. The Hudson plans and coordinates treatment at partner clinics in Hanoi; we are not a clinic. About the author.

Ask us about your case.

Talk to us