Why is there a dark line at the gum on my old crown, and should I replace it?
A dark or grey line at the gum on an old crown is usually the metal inside a porcelain-fused-to-metal crown. When the crown was made, its edge sat just under the gum. Gums often shrink back over the years: in one long study, 65% of crown edges were under the gum at the start and only 41% five years later (Valderhaug and Birkeland 1976). The metal edge, or a darker root, then shows. On its own the line is a cosmetic matter, and a crown that is sound, sealed and comfortable does not need replacing for health reasons. Replace it, or have it checked soon, if the line comes with decay, a gap you can catch with a fingernail, bleeding, a bad taste or a loose crown, because decay at the edge is the most common reason crowns fail (De Backer 2006). If it is only the look that bothers you, a metal-free crown is a reasonable choice, and the dentist should check the tooth under it first.
The dark line, at a glance
| What you see | Most likely cause | Health problem? | Usual next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| A thin grey or black band right at the gum, even and smooth | The metal edge of a porcelain-fused-to-metal crown, showing after the gum shrank back | Usually not | Leave it, or replace for the look |
| A grey shadow through the gum above the crown | Metal under thin gum, or a dark root under the crown | Usually not | Leave it, or replace for the look; a dark root may need more than a new crown |
| A dark line with a step, gap or rough edge you can catch | A crown edge that no longer seals | Possibly | See a dentist and have an X-ray |
| Brown or black at the edge with a soft spot, sensitivity or a bad taste | Decay at the crown edge | Yes | See a dentist soon |
| Red, puffy gum that bleeds around the crown | Gum inflammation, often from plaque at the crown edge | Yes, for the gum | Cleaning and a check of the crown edge |
| A dark line on a crown that also feels loose | Cement washed out, often with decay under it | Yes | See a dentist soon |
The short version: an even, smooth dark line on a crown that feels fine is usually cosmetic. A dark line plus any sign of trouble is a reason to see a dentist, not just a reason to change the crown.
Why old crowns show a dark line
For decades, the standard crown was porcelain fused to metal, often shortened to PFM. A thin metal shell sits on the tooth for strength, and tooth-coloured porcelain is baked over it. Many older crowns are this kind, and they are still made today.
The metal is hidden in two ways. The porcelain covers it on the outside, and the edge of the crown is tucked just under the gum line, so the gum hides the last millimetre. Over time, three things can undo that:
- The gum shrinks back. This is called gum recession. It is common in adults and becomes more common with age, even in people who clean well (Serino 1994).
- The edge was never fully hidden. Some crowns were made with a visible metal collar, or with the edge at the gum rather than under it.
- The tooth under the crown darkened. A tooth with an old root canal or a metal post can turn grey, and the root above the crown edge shows it.
Recession around crowns is well documented. In a group of 114 patients given crowns and bridges, 65% of the crown edges sat under the gum at the start. Five years later only 41% did, because the gum had moved (Valderhaug and Birkeland 1976). The crowns had not changed. The gum around them had.
Metal can also show as a shadow through thin gum. In a trial of implant crowns, crowns on metal had a more visible effect on the colour of the gum next to them than all-ceramic crowns did (Jung 2008). Thin gum over the metal edge of a crown on a natural tooth can show the same grey tinge.
When the line is only cosmetic
Metal at the edge of a crown is not a health problem by itself. The metal does not rot, and the line does not mean the crown is failing. If all of the points below are true, the dark line is most likely a matter of looks:
- The line is even and smooth, and a fingernail or floss slides over the crown edge without catching.
- The gum around the crown is pink, firm and does not bleed when you brush.
- There is no sensitivity, ache or bad taste from that tooth.
- The crown does not move or click when you bite.
- A recent X-ray showed no decay or infection at that tooth.
Metal-ceramic crowns have a long record. In a large review, 94.7% of metal-ceramic single crowns were still in place after five years, a rate similar to most all-ceramic crowns (Sailer 2015). In an 18-year study of 1,037 crowns, 78% were still in place at 18 years (De Backer 2006). A working metal-ceramic crown has often decades of service behind it, and it can have years ahead of it.
Replacing a sound crown for the look is a fair choice, as long as you know what it involves. Taking off a crown means cutting through it, and the tooth under it is usually trimmed again for the new crown. Each new crown takes a little more tooth. Our article on how much tooth a crown removes explains why that matters for the long-term life of the tooth.
When the dark line means decay or a failing edge
Sometimes the dark line is not metal at all, or not only metal. Decay at the edge of a crown, called secondary or recurrent decay, looks brown or black and often starts exactly where the crown meets the tooth. It is the most common reason crowns are removed. In the 18-year study of crowns, decay was the most frequent cause of failure (De Backer 2006). In general practice, decay next to an existing restoration is also the main reason fillings are replaced (Mjör 2000).
The risk grows with time. In a 15-year study of bridges, decay was found on 3.3% of the support tooth surfaces at 5 years, 10.0% at 10 years and 12.0% at 15 years (Valderhaug 1993). In a review of complications, about 3% of single crowns needed root canal treatment and about 2% came loose (Goodacre 2003).
Signs that the line needs a dentist, not just a decision
- A step or gap at the edge that catches floss or a fingernail.
- Brown, black or chalky white tooth showing just below the crown.
- Sensitivity to cold or sweet at that tooth.
- A bad taste, a bad smell from that spot, or floss that comes out smelling.
- Gum that is red, swollen or bleeds around that crown.
- A crown that feels loose, clicks or lets food in.
- Pain on biting, or a pimple on the gum above the tooth.
Gum health matters around old crowns. Edges placed under the gum had more gum inflammation over 10 and 15 years than edges at or above the gum (Valderhaug 1980; Valderhaug 1993). That does not mean the crown must come out. It means that crown needs good cleaning, and a check at each visit.
Your situation, and the usual choice
| Your situation | Usual choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Back tooth, line hardly seen, crown sound | Leave it | No health reason to change it, and no one sees it |
| Front tooth, line shows when you smile, crown sound | Your choice: leave it, or replace it with a metal-free crown | A purely cosmetic decision; ask about the tooth under it first |
| Line plus decay, a gap or a loose crown | Replace the crown after treating the tooth | The seal has failed; decay spreads under a loose crown |
| Line from a grey root after a root canal | A new crown may not hide it; ask about the root and the gum | The colour comes from the tooth, not only the crown |
| Several old front crowns, one with a line | Plan them together | Matching shade and shape across the smile is easier in one plan |
| Gum recession still getting worse | Treat the gum cause first | A new crown edge can be exposed again if the gum keeps shrinking |
| You grind your teeth heavily | Discuss the material | Strength at the back may matter more than the line |
There is no rule that a crown must be replaced after a set number of years. A crown is replaced when it fails, when the tooth under it needs treatment, or when you want a different look.
What replacing an old crown involves
- Records first: X-rays, photos of your smile and a scan of your bite, so the new crown can copy what works.
- The old crown is cut off. Metal-ceramic crowns are cut through and lifted off; they cannot be reused.
- The tooth is checked: decay is cleaned out, the root canal and any post are checked, and a crack or a weak root is looked for.
- Treatment if needed: a filling under the crown, a new root canal, or gum treatment.
- The tooth is shaped for the new crown, and a scan or impression goes to the lab.
- A temporary crown is fitted while the lab makes the new one.
- The new crown is tried in, the shade and fit are checked, and it is fixed in place.
The surprise, when there is one, comes at step three. Decay or a crack is often hidden under a crown until it is off. Ask the dentist what happens if the tooth turns out to be weaker than it looked, so you know the options before the crown is cut.
If the tooth needs a root canal before the new crown, see How much is a root canal and crown together? for what that adds.
Which crown hides the line
A crown with no metal has no metal edge to show. The common metal-free choices are zirconia, which is strong and suits back and front teeth, and lithium disilicate (E-max), a glass ceramic often used for front teeth. Our page on zirconia vs E-max crowns compares them in detail.
- Metal-free crowns: no metal edge, so recession later shows tooth-coloured crown or root, not a dark band.
- A dark tooth under the crown: some ceramics let more light through than others. A very dark root may need a more opaque crown, or extra work on the tooth first.
- Gum level: if the gum is still receding, any crown edge can show later. Treating the cause first protects the new crown.
- Matching: a new front crown next to old ones may not match. Some people replace a group of front crowns together for an even smile.
Brand and price do not decide how natural a crown looks. Shade, shape and the lab's finishing work do. A well-made crown in any of the brands on our list can blend in.
What it costs to replace a crown in Vietnam
Zirconia crowns at our partner clinics in Vietnam cost A$222 to A$971 per tooth, depending on the brand. That range runs from the lowest to the highest crown on the price list below. Replacing one crown with DD Bio costs A$333, and replacing a group of six front crowns costs A$1,332 to A$5,826, which is the per-tooth price times six.
| Brand | Per tooth | 16 teeth | 20 teeth | Lab warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard | ||||
| Katana | A$222 | A$3,560 | A$4,440 | 7 years |
| Ceramill | A$286 | A$4,580 | A$5,720 | 10 years |
| DD Bio | A$333 | A$5,330 | A$6,660 | 10 years |
| Plus | ||||
| Origin Beyond Plus | A$357 | A$5,720 | A$7,140 | 10 years |
| Lava Plus | A$444 | A$7,110 | A$8,880 | 15 years |
| Lava Esthetic | A$554 | A$8,870 | A$11,080 | 15 years |
| Premium | ||||
| Orodent Bleach | A$666 | A$10,050 | A$12,560 | 19 years |
| Origin Apex | A$971 | A$15,540 | A$19,420 | 15 years |
Updated Nov 2026
Free flight& hotelClaim nowT&Cs apply
Updated Nov 2026. Ask the clinic whether taking off the old crown is included in the new crown price, and have it written on the quote. A root canal or post, if the tooth needs one, is extra.
In Australia, a crown (ADA item 615, a layered crown) cost A$1,678 on average at a general dentist in 2022, and A$1,250 to A$2,100 across most practices (ADA Dental Fees Survey 2022, via Choice).
For one back crown that is only a cosmetic issue, a trip rarely makes sense. For several front crowns, or when other work is planned too, the numbers change. Our page on whether it is worth going overseas for crowns works through the trip maths.
What this means if you fly from Australia to Vietnam
- Replacing crowns usually fits one trip. Our page on how many days crowns take in Vietnam sets out the days.
- Send recent X-rays and a photo of the dark line before you fly. The clinic can tell you whether it looks cosmetic or like decay.
- Expect the final plan to wait until the old crown is off. Allow a spare day in case the tooth needs a root canal first.
- If several front crowns are involved, plan them in one trip so the shade and shape match.
- Ask for copies of the X-rays and the crown details, so your dentist at home knows what was done.
Questions to ask the dentist
- Is the dark line metal, a dark root, or decay?
- Does the crown edge still seal, and what does the X-ray show at that tooth?
- Is my gum still receding, and should that be treated first?
- If I replace the crown for the look, how much more tooth will be trimmed?
- Will a metal-free crown hide the colour of this tooth, or is the root dark too?
- Should the crowns next to it be replaced too, so they match?
- What happens if you find decay or a crack once the old crown is off?
Common beliefs that are not quite right
- "A dark line means the crown is rotting." Usually it is the metal edge showing after the gum shrank back. Decay is possible, and an X-ray tells them apart.
- "Metal crowns are bad for you." Metal-ceramic crowns have a long record of lasting (Sailer 2015). The issue is how they look when the edge shows.
- "Crowns must be replaced every 10 to 15 years." A crown is replaced when it fails or when you choose a new look, not on a timetable.
- "A new crown will fix the gum recession." A new crown covers the exposed edge, but it does not stop the gum shrinking.
- "A metal-free crown always hides a dark tooth." A very dark root can still show through some ceramics.
Where the evidence is thin
No study has followed people who replaced sound metal-ceramic crowns purely for looks, so the benefit is judged case by case. Most long crown studies come from university clinics in Europe, and newer metal-free crowns have shorter follow-up than metal-ceramic ones (Sailer 2015).
Quick answers
Is the black line on my crown decay?
Usually not. Most often it is the metal edge of a porcelain-fused-to-metal crown, showing after the gum shrank back. Decay is brown or black too, so an X-ray and a check of the edge tell them apart.
Can the dark line on a crown be fixed without a new crown?
Sometimes the gum can be treated, or a tooth-coloured filling placed over exposed root. If the line is the metal of the crown itself, a new metal-free crown is the usual way to remove it.
Why is my gum grey above my crown?
Metal inside the crown, or a dark root after a root canal, can show through thin gum as a grey shadow. It is usually cosmetic; red, swollen or bleeding gum is a different problem.
Do old metal crowns need replacing?
Not by age alone. A metal-ceramic crown that seals, feels fine and shows no decay on an X-ray can stay. Replace it if it fails, if the tooth needs treatment, or if you want a different look.
Will a new crown show a dark line again?
A metal-free crown has no metal edge to show. If your gum keeps shrinking, the root above the crown can still show, so treat the cause of the recession first.
Not sure what your dark line is?
Send us a photo and a recent X-ray. We pass them to the dentist at a partner clinic in Vietnam, who tells you whether it looks cosmetic or like decay, and what replacing the crown would involve. Free.
Send us a photoSources
- Valderhaug J, Birkeland JM. Periodontal conditions in patients 5 years following insertion of fixed prostheses. J Oral Rehabil, 1976.
- Valderhaug J. Periodontal conditions and carious lesions following the insertion of fixed prostheses: a 10-year follow-up study. Int Dent J, 1980.
- Valderhaug J, Ellingsen JE, Jokstad A. Oral hygiene, periodontal conditions and carious lesions in patients treated with dental bridges. A 15-year clinical and radiographic follow-up study. J Clin Periodontol, 1993.
- Serino G et al. The prevalence and distribution of gingival recession in subjects with a high standard of oral hygiene. J Clin Periodontol, 1994.
- Jung RE et al. The effect of all-ceramic and porcelain-fused-to-metal restorations on marginal peri-implant soft tissue color: a randomized controlled clinical trial. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent, 2008.
- Sailer I et al. All-ceramic or metal-ceramic tooth-supported fixed dental prostheses (FDPs)? A systematic review of the survival and complication rates. Part I: Single crowns. Dent Mater, 2015.
- De Backer H et al. An 18-year retrospective survival study of full crowns with or without posts. Int J Prosthodont, 2006.
- Goodacre CJ et al. Clinical complications in fixed prosthodontics. J Prosthet Dent, 2003.
- Mjör IA, Moorhead JE, Dahl JE. Reasons for replacement of restorations in permanent teeth in general dental practice. Int Dent J, 2000.
- Choice. Dental fees: ADA Dental Fees Survey 2022.