Should I replace my old silver (amalgam) fillings, and with what?
Not for health reasons alone. The FDA (2020) and the Australian Dental Association (2025) both say sound amalgam fillings do not need to come out, and the FDA notes that drilling them out briefly raises the mercury vapour you breathe. Replace a silver filling when it is failing: cracked, leaking, decayed at the edge, broken, or under a tooth that has cracked. Small ones are usually replaced with a white composite filling; large ones on back teeth often need an onlay (a ceramic piece that covers the cusps) or a crown, because the tooth around a big old filling is weak. Every replacement removes some healthy tooth, so a dental trip is a poor time to "do them all" at once. At our partner clinics in Vietnam a crown costs A$222 to A$971 per tooth.
- Sound amalgam fillings: no need to remove (FDA 2020; Australian Dental Association 2025).
- Removing all fillings in one session raised blood mercury by about 32% for up to 48 hours, then levels fell (Sandborgh-Englund 1998).
- Ceramic inlays and onlays: about 91% still in place at 10 years (Morimoto 2016, 14 studies).
Silver fillings at a glance
| Question | Short answer |
|---|---|
| Are my old silver fillings dangerous? | Not for most people. Sound fillings do not need removing (FDA 2020; ADA 2025) |
| Who should avoid new amalgam? | Pregnant or breastfeeding women, young children and some others; see below |
| When should one be replaced? | When it is cracked, leaking, decayed at the edge, broken, or the tooth has cracked |
| Small filling, replaced with | A white composite (resin) filling |
| Large filling, replaced with | An onlay or a crown, which protect the weakened cusps |
| Does removal harm the tooth? | Yes, a little: some healthy tooth is always lost when a filling is drilled out |
| Do them all on a trip? | No. Replace the ones that are failing; leave the sound ones |
| Price in Vietnam | Crowns A$222 to A$971 per tooth at our partner clinics; fillings and onlays priced at the check-up |
Each row is explained below. ADA here means the Australian Dental Association.
What a silver filling is
Dental amalgam is a mix of metals, mainly silver, tin and copper, bound together with mercury. It has been used to fill back teeth for more than a century because it is strong, lasts a long time and is forgiving to place. Over the years it turns darker, and on a big filling the grey can show through the tooth.
Once set, the mercury is bound in the alloy, but a filling releases tiny amounts of mercury vapour, more when it is chewed on, ground or drilled. That is the root of the safety question.
Are old amalgam fillings safe?
For the general population, the official answer in Australia and the United States is yes, and neither body advises removing sound fillings.
| Body | What it says |
|---|---|
| US Food and Drug Administration, 2020 | Not recommending anyone remove or replace existing amalgam fillings in good condition unless medically necessary; removal can briefly raise mercury vapour exposure |
| Australian Dental Association, 2025 | Amalgam remains safe for the general population; existing fillings do not pose health risks; no evidence for routine removal except allergy or a specific medical need |
| Dental Board of Australia, 2022 | Amalgam can still be used, but is not recommended for baby teeth, patients under 15, or pregnant and breastfeeding women unless the dentist judges it necessary |
| European Union, from 1 January 2025 | Amalgam no longer used for dental treatment except when strictly necessary for a patient's medical needs |
The FDA's 2020 advice names groups who may be at greater risk and should avoid new amalgam where possible: pregnant women, women planning a pregnancy, nursing women, children, especially under 6, people with existing neurological disease, people with impaired kidney function, and people with a known allergy to mercury or amalgam. Even for these groups, it did not recommend removing fillings that are in good condition.
Why amalgam is being phased out anyway
The phase-out is about the environment, not about fillings already in people's mouths. Under the Minamata Convention on Mercury, a United Nations treaty, delegates from 153 countries agreed in late 2025 to end the manufacture, import and export of dental amalgam from 2034. The Australian Dental Association described this as a gradual, environmental step and repeated that existing fillings are safe.
What removal does to mercury levels
Drilling out amalgam turns some of it into fine particles and vapour. In a study of 12 healthy adults who had all their amalgam fillings removed in one session, an average of 18 surfaces each, blood mercury rose by about 32% within 48 hours. Levels then fell steadily, and 60 days later were about 60% of what they had been before removal (Sandborgh-Englund 1998). So removal adds a short spike in exposure, and the long-term level falls afterwards. Neither change has been shown to matter for health in people without an allergy.
The one clear medical reason: lichenoid reactions
A small number of people develop white or red patches on the cheek or tongue right next to an amalgam filling, called an oral lichenoid reaction. In a study of 134 such patients, removing the amalgam improved the patches in 102 of 105 who had it done, and cleared them completely in about 3 in 10, while only 2 of 29 who kept their fillings improved (Dunsche 2003). If you have sore patches touching a filling, show a dentist; this is a reason for removal that the ADA's position also allows.
When an old filling really needs replacing
Amalgam fillings often last decades. The reason to replace one is that it, or the tooth around it, is failing. These are the signs a dentist looks for:
- Decay at the edge: a dark shadow under or beside the filling on an X-ray, where bacteria have got in.
- A gap or ditch at the edge, where food catches.
- A broken or missing piece of filling.
- Cracks in the tooth: fine lines running out from the filling, or a piece of cusp, one of the points of the tooth, breaking away.
- Pain on biting, especially sharp pain when you release the bite. That can mean a crack in the tooth, which is more common around large fillings.
- An allergy or lichenoid reaction, as above.
- You do not like the look. On a tooth that shows when you smile, this is a fair reason, as long as you know what removal costs in tooth.
A filling that is old and dark but sealed, with no decay, cracks or symptoms, is not failing. Age alone is not a reason.
What to replace it with: filling, onlay or crown
| Size of the old filling | Usual replacement | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Small, one surface | White composite filling | Bonds to the tooth; little extra drilling |
| Medium, two or three surfaces, cusps strong | Composite filling, or an inlay | Composite is fine if enough wall remains; an inlay is made by a lab and fitted into the cavity |
| Large, a cusp weak or cracked | Onlay | Covers and protects the cusps while keeping the healthy sides of the tooth |
| Very large, little tooth left, or after a root canal | Crown | Holds the whole tooth together |
| A crack reaching the nerve | Root canal, then a crown | The crown protects the root-treated tooth |
Composite against amalgam
White composite fillings look like teeth and bond to them, but on back teeth they have not quite matched amalgam's record. A Cochrane review of the two large randomised trials, in 921 children, found composite fillings almost twice as likely to fail (risk ratio 1.89) and about twice as likely to get new decay at the edge, with no difference in the filling itself breaking. It rated the evidence low certainty (Worthington 2021). An earlier review reached the same conclusion (Moraschini 2015). For large fillings of two or more surfaces, a 2025 review found too few trials to say either material does better (Santos 2025).
In other words, swapping a sound amalgam for a composite trades a filling that is working for one that, on average, does not last quite as long. That is fine when the amalgam is failing anyway; less so when it is not.
Onlays and crowns
When an old filling is large, the cusps around it have often been thinned for years. A ceramic onlay covers those cusps from the top, so biting force is spread across the tooth instead of wedging it apart. A review of 14 studies found ceramic inlays, onlays and overlays about 92% to 95% intact at 5 years and 91% at 10 years. Fractures and chipping were the commonest reason for failure, and the tooth's nerve being alive at the start lowered the risk (Morimoto 2016).
A crown goes further and covers the whole tooth. It is the right choice when too little tooth is left for an onlay, or after a root canal. For deciding between them, see do I need a crown, which compares an onlay and a crown in detail.
What removal costs in tooth
Every time a filling is replaced, the cavity gets a little bigger. The dentist has to drill out the old material and some tooth with it, and clean back to sound tooth around any decay. Teeth often go through a cycle over a lifetime: small filling, bigger filling, onlay or crown, root canal.
| Preparation | Tooth removed |
|---|---|
| Small bonded preparation | About 5.5% |
| Inlay across three surfaces | About 27% |
| Full crown | About 67.5% to 75.6% |
These figures were measured on model teeth prepared from scratch, not on teeth with old fillings, but they show the scale: a full crown removes most of the outer tooth, while bonded fillings and inlays remove much less. That is why a dentist who follows current thinking chooses the smallest repair that will hold, and why a repair can beat a replacement. In a 10-year trial of old amalgam fillings with small defects, repairing them did as well as replacing them in people at low or medium risk of decay, while saving tooth (Moncada 2015).
Why a dental trip is a bad time to do them all
It is tempting to plan a trip to Vietnam and have every old silver filling swapped while you are there. For most people this is a mistake, for four reasons:
- Sound fillings have no medical reason to come out (FDA 2020; ADA 2025).
- Each replacement removes healthy tooth, and the next repair will be bigger again.
- Composite fillings on back teeth fail somewhat more often than amalgam on average (Worthington 2021), so swapping working fillings can create work later.
- Removing many large fillings at once can uncover cracks and deep decay. Some of those teeth then need a root canal or a crown, which can turn a simple plan into a much larger one in the middle of a trip.
A sensible plan is to have every filling assessed at the check-up with X-rays, and to treat only those that are failing, plus any that you and the dentist agree are worth changing for looks on teeth that show. The rest can be watched at your normal check-ups at home.
If crowns are already planned on teeth that have old amalgam fillings, the amalgam is removed as part of shaping the tooth for the crown. That is not an extra step; the dentist builds the tooth up with a white core filling before the crown is made.
What it costs
At our partner clinics in Vietnam, a crown costs A$222 to A$971 per tooth, depending on the material, from The Hudson price list, November 2026. If a tooth needs a root canal first, that adds about A$167, and a post and core about A$111 if needed, so a root canal and crown comes to A$389 to A$1,249.
Method: the low end is the root canal (A$167) plus the lowest crown (A$222); the high end adds the post and core (A$111) and the highest crown (A$971). White fillings and onlays are not on The Hudson price list; the clinic prices them per tooth after the check-up and X-rays.
In Australia, a crown at a general dentist averaged about A$1,250 to A$2,100 by state in the ADA's 2022 fee survey, reported by Choice. A filling takes one visit and is simple to have done at home. A trip makes most sense when crowns or onlays are needed, which take several days and a lab.
Choice by situation
| Your situation | Usual advice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Old silver fillings, no symptoms, X-rays clear | Leave them; check at each visit | No health reason to remove them (FDA 2020; ADA 2025) |
| A filling with decay at the edge | Replace it, usually with composite | The decay has to be removed anyway |
| A large filling and a cracked cusp | Onlay or crown | Protects the weak cusps from splitting |
| Sharp pain on biting near a big filling | Check for a cracked tooth before deciding | May need an onlay, a crown, or a root canal and crown |
| Pregnant, breastfeeding or planning a pregnancy | Avoid elective removal; plan new fillings without amalgam | FDA high-risk group; removal briefly raises exposure |
| Sore patches touching a filling | See a dentist about a lichenoid reaction | Removal helped most patients in one study (Dunsche 2003) |
| Grey showing through a front or smiling tooth | Composite, onlay or crown, by size | A fair cosmetic reason, weighed against tooth lost |
Questions to ask the dentist
- Which of my fillings are actually failing, and how can you tell?
- Can you show me on the X-ray?
- For this tooth, would you repair, refill, onlay or crown it, and why?
- How much healthy tooth will be lost?
- Do I have signs of a cracked tooth?
- If you find more decay once the old filling is out, what will you do, and what will it cost?
- Which fillings can wait and be watched at home?
Common beliefs that are not quite right
- "Silver fillings slowly poison you." The FDA and the Australian Dental Association both say sound fillings do not need removing for most people.
- "Taking them out lowers my risk straight away." Removal briefly raises mercury levels before they fall (Sandborgh-Englund 1998).
- "White fillings are always better." They look better and bond to the tooth, but on back teeth they failed somewhat more often in the trials (Worthington 2021).
- "Old means it needs replacing." A sealed filling with no decay or cracks can keep working for years.
- "The phase-out means amalgam is unsafe." The Minamata phase-out is an environmental measure about mercury in industry and waste.
How we make money
You don't pay us anything. When you go ahead with treatment, the clinic pays us a referral fee for each patient. It doesn't change your price: you pay the clinic's normal price, the same as if you walked in yourself.
Quick answers
Should I have my amalgam fillings removed for my health?
Not if they are sound. The FDA (2020) and the Australian Dental Association (2025) do not recommend removing fillings in good condition.
Is it safe to remove amalgam fillings?
Yes, but drilling them out briefly raises mercury exposure, which is one reason sound fillings are left alone.
What is the replacement for a large silver filling?
Often an onlay or a crown, because the tooth around a large old filling is weak. Small ones are usually replaced with a white filling.
Is amalgam banned in Australia?
No. It can still be used, but the Dental Board advises against it for children under 15 and pregnant or breastfeeding women. A global phase-out is set for 2034.
Can I replace all my silver fillings on a dental trip?
You can, but it is rarely wise. Replace the failing ones and keep the sound ones; each replacement removes healthy tooth.
Not sure which old fillings need work?
Send us a recent X-ray or your dentist's notes. We will ask our partner clinic in Vietnam which teeth need a filling, onlay or crown, and which are fine to leave. Free.
Check my fillingsSources
- Vietnam prices: The Hudson price list, November 2026 (partner clinics in Vietnam).
- US Food and Drug Administration: FDA issues recommendations for certain high-risk groups regarding mercury-containing dental amalgam, 24 September 2020.
- Australian Dental Association: Mercury amalgam global phase-out date set for 2034, 11 November 2025.
- Dental Board of Australia: position statement on the Minamata Convention on Mercury, 8 November 2022.
- European Parliament legislative summary: dental amalgam and other mercury-added products (Regulation (EU) 2024/1849).
- Sandborgh-Englund G et al. Mercury in biological fluids after amalgam removal. J Dent Res, 1998.
- Dunsche A et al. Oral lichenoid reactions associated with amalgam: improvement after amalgam removal. Br J Dermatol, 2003.
- Worthington HV et al. Direct composite resin fillings versus amalgam fillings for permanent posterior teeth. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2021.
- Moraschini V et al. Amalgam and resin composite longevity of posterior restorations: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent, 2015.
- Santos M et al. Clinical longevity of complex direct posterior resin composite and amalgam restorations: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Oper Dent, 2025.
- Morimoto S et al. Survival rate of resin and ceramic inlays, onlays, and overlays: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent Res, 2016.
- Edelhoff D, Sorensen JA. Tooth structure removal associated with various preparation designs for posterior teeth. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent, 2002.
- Moncada G et al. Longitudinal results of a 10-year clinical trial of repair of amalgam restorations. Oper Dent, 2015.
- Choice: Dental fees, ADA Dental Fees Survey 2022 (crown item 615, by state).