Root canal and crown, or take the tooth out and get an implant?
If the tooth can be saved with a good outlook, a root canal and crown is usually the first choice. In the studies, restored root-filled teeth and single implants survive about equally well (Iqbal and Kim 2007; Borda 2025), and implants needed more follow-up treatment to keep them going (Doyle 2006; Hannahan and Eleazer 2008). An implant is the better plan when the tooth is split through the root, has too little left above the gum to hold a crown, or sits in bone badly damaged by gum disease. At our partner clinics in Vietnam, a root canal and crown costs A$389 to A$1,249 per tooth, and a single implant tooth costs A$786 to A$3,102 or more, plus the extraction. A root canal and crown fits in one trip; an implant takes two.
Root canal and crown, or implant, at a glance
| Root canal and crown | Extraction and implant | |
|---|---|---|
| Your own tooth | Kept | Taken out and replaced |
| Survival in the studies | About the same as an implant | About the same as a root-filled tooth |
| Extra treatment later | Less often needed in the comparisons | More often needed: 12.4% against 1.3% in one study |
| Surgery | No | Yes: extraction, then the implant |
| Time until you chew on it | Days | Months, while the bone heals |
| Trips to Vietnam | Usually one | Two, 3 to 6 months apart |
| Price at our partner clinics | A$389 to A$1,249 | A$786 to A$3,102 or more, plus the extraction |
| Price in Australia | about A$2,150 to A$5,800 | about A$3,500 to A$6,000 |
| Usually the right choice when | Enough sound tooth and bone remain | The tooth is split, crumbling below the gum, or very loose |
Survival figures are from the studies named below. How the prices are built is set out in the price section further down. Updated Nov 2026.
What each treatment involves
A root canal treats the inside of the tooth. The dentist removes the infected or dead nerve (the pulp), cleans and shapes the canals inside the roots, and seals them. The tooth is then weaker and more brittle, so a back tooth almost always needs a crown on top. A crown is a cap that covers the whole visible part of the tooth. If very little tooth is left, a post and core is added first to give the crown something to hold on to.
An implant replaces the tooth completely. The tooth is taken out. A titanium screw is placed in the jawbone, either on the same day or after the socket heals. Bone grows tightly onto the screw over the following months. A connector and a crown are then fixed on top.
- With a root canal, your own root stays in the bone, with its natural cushioning ligament and the gum shape around it.
- With an implant, nothing of the old tooth is left. It cannot decay, but the gum and bone around it can become infected (peri-implantitis), and screws and crowns can work loose.
- Both need a crown. The crown is often the part that needs repair first, whichever you choose.
Root canal prices by tooth, timing between the root canal and the crown, and whether you need a post are covered on the root canal and crown cost page. This page is about the choice itself.
Which lasts longer? What the studies found
Many studies have asked this question, and they keep reaching the same answer: when a tooth can be properly treated, keeping it and replacing it with an implant end up with similar survival. The difference is in what happens along the way. A 2014 review of both fields still describes when to keep a tooth and when to replace it as a live debate among dentists (Setzer and Kim 2014).
| Study | What was compared | What they found |
|---|---|---|
| Torabinejad 2007, review of 143 studies | Root canal and crown, single implants, bridges, and extraction with no replacement | Long-term survival of implants and root-filled teeth was similar, and better than bridges |
| Iqbal and Kim 2007, review | 55 studies of single implants and 13 of restored root-filled teeth | No significant difference in survival at any follow-up period |
| Doyle 2006, matched groups | 196 implants and 196 root-filled teeth | Failure 6.1% in both groups; 17.9% of implants needed extra treatment to survive, against 3.6% of teeth |
| Hannahan and Eleazer 2008 | 129 implants and 143 root-filled teeth | Success 98.4% and 99.3%; 12.4% of implants needed further treatment, against 1.3% of teeth |
| Sinsareekul 2025, review of 8 studies | Studies comparing the two directly | Results split: some favoured implants over time, others favoured teeth. Which lasts longer was unclear |
| Borda 2025, review of 12 studies | Root canal treatment and implants for badly damaged teeth | Failure 0.7% to 12.0%, with no significant difference; implants had more follow-up treatment and complications |
Two things stand out. First, the survival numbers overlap. A review of 55 implant studies and 13 tooth studies found the ranges overlapping at every time point, and concluded that the choice should rest on other factors (Iqbal and Kim 2007). Second, implants more often needed something done afterwards: tightening, bone or gum treatment, or a new part (Doyle 2006; Hannahan and Eleazer 2008; Borda 2025).
Patients were satisfied with both. The 2025 review by Borda found pain, satisfaction and quality of life were comparable for the two. The 2025 review by Sinsareekul noted clear gains in oral health quality of life after root canal treatment.
A broader review that only took studies of 15 years or more found tooth loss of 3.6% to 13.4% for treated teeth and implant loss of 0% to 33% (Levin 2013). The authors noted that a tooth can be taken out and replaced at any time, while extraction cannot be undone.
Why the success rates look so different between studies
You will find claims online that implants are 98% successful and root canals only 85%, or the other way round. Those numbers usually measure different things.
- Survival means the tooth or implant is still in the mouth. Success means it is also healthy by a stricter test, such as no shadow on the X-ray around the root, or less than a set amount of bone loss around the implant.
- Root canal studies often use strict X-ray healing as success. Implant studies often count an implant as a success as long as it is in place and not loose.
- The largest review on this choice found success rules differed so much between the two treatments that comparing success rates directly was pointless. Survival was the fair comparison, and it was similar (Torabinejad 2007).
- Who did the work matters too. In one comparison, periodontists placed the implants and endodontists did the root canals, both dentists with further training in that field (Hannahan and Eleazer 2008).
So compare survival with survival. On that measure, a properly treated tooth and an implant come out close.
When saving the tooth makes sense
- There is enough sound tooth above the gum for a crown to grip, usually a band of healthy tooth all the way round.
- The root is not cracked or split.
- The bone around the root is reasonably healthy, and the tooth is not very loose.
- The canals can be reached and cleaned, which the dentist judges from the X-ray and 3D scan.
- You want to keep your own tooth, and the dentist rates the outlook as good.
- The tooth is at the front, where keeping the natural gum shape matters for the look.
Keeping a tooth also keeps your options open. If the root-filled tooth fails years later, an implant is still possible then. The reverse is not true: once the tooth is out, it is gone.
When an implant is the better plan
- The root is split from top to bottom (a vertical root fracture). These teeth cannot be repaired.
- Decay runs deep below the gum and into the bone, so there is nothing sound left for a crown.
- Gum disease has destroyed most of the bone around the root and the tooth is very loose.
- A root canal has already failed, retreatment has a poor outlook, and surgery on the root tip is not suitable.
- The tooth would need a root canal, gum surgery, crown lengthening and a post all at once, each adding risk.
In those cases the effort to save the tooth may cost more than an implant and still leave a weak tooth. A good dentist says so plainly, and shows you on the X-ray or scan why.
If a root canal has already failed
A tooth with an old root canal that is infected again is not automatically lost. There are two ways to try to save it: redo the root canal (retreatment), or remove the infected root tip through the gum (root-end surgery, also called an apicoectomy).
- A review of 17 studies found retreatment healed completely in about 77% of teeth (Ng 2008). A large infection at the root tip, a short root filling and a poor crown lowered the chances.
- A US cost study of a failed root canal in a first molar ranked root-end surgery as the most cost-effective option, then retreatment and a crown, then a bridge, and a single implant last, based on 2009 US fees (Kim and Solomon 2011).
Fees in Vietnam are lower and the ranking of costs may differ, but the logic holds: try to save a sound root first, and move to an implant when the outlook for the root is poor.
What it costs, in Vietnam and in Australia
| Vietnam (our partner clinics) | Australia | |
|---|---|---|
| Root canal | A$167 | about A$900 to A$3,700, by tooth and dentist |
| Post and core, only if needed | A$111 | ask your dentist |
| Crown | A$222 to A$971 | about A$1,250 to A$2,100 |
| Root canal and crown, total | A$389 to A$1,249 | about A$2,150 to A$5,800 |
| Extraction | Priced after the scan | Extra |
| Bone graft, only if needed | A$277 per site | Extra |
| Implant tooth (implant, connector and crown) | A$786 to A$3,102 or more | about A$3,500 to A$6,000 |
- How the Vietnam root canal and crown total is built: the root canal at A$167 (one price for any tooth) plus a zirconia crown from A$222 to A$971 by brand. The top of the range also adds a post and core at A$111, for a tooth that needs one.
- How the Vietnam implant price is built: the price of one full implant tooth (implant, the maker's own connector and a crown) from the lowest to the highest brand on our list, A$786 to A$3,102. The top brand is priced "from". The extraction and any bone graft are added on top.
- Australian root canal and crown: root canal fees by tooth from Compare Dentists' 2026 price guide (general dentist to endodontist), plus a crown at about A$1,250 to A$2,100 from the Australian Dental Association's 2022 fee survey (via Choice). The low end is a front tooth with a general dentist, the high end a molar with an endodontist.
- Australian implant: about A$3,500 to A$6,000 for one implant with its connector and crown, from Compare Dentists, based on the Australian Dental Association fee survey (updated June 2026). Extraction and any graft are extra.
Two costs are easy to miss. An implant adds a second trip, with flights and a hotel. A root-filled tooth needs its crown on time, and both options need check-ups for years. Compare the whole plan, not one line.
Which choice fits your situation?
| Your situation | Usual choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Toothache or abscess, tooth otherwise solid | Root canal and crown | Survival is similar to an implant, with fewer follow-up treatments |
| Old root canal infected again, root sound | Retreatment or root-end surgery first | Many of these teeth heal, and the root stays |
| Root split from top to bottom | Extraction and implant | A split root cannot be repaired |
| Broken off at or below the gum | Usually an implant | Nothing sound is left for a crown to grip |
| Very loose tooth with heavy bone loss | Usually extraction, then plan the gap | The root has too little support left |
| Front tooth, good root, worried about the look | Usually keep the tooth | Your own root holds the natural gum shape |
| Only one trip possible | Root canal and crown, if the tooth allows | An implant needs a second trip months later |
What this means for a trip from Australia to Vietnam
Send an X-ray of the tooth, and a 3D scan if you have one, before you book. The dentist at the partner clinic can usually say from these whether the tooth looks worth saving, and confirm it in the chair.
- Root canal and crown: usually one trip. The root canal comes first, then the crown is made and fitted a few days later. If there is an active infection, the dentist may want it to settle first, which can add days.
- Extraction and implant: two trips of about 7 days each, 3 to 6 months apart while the bone heals. The tooth comes out on the first trip, the implant goes in then or after healing, and the final crown is fitted on the second trip.
- A bone graft, if needed, fits within the same two trips.
At home, a root-filled tooth can feel tender to bite on for a few days. Swelling, a bad taste or a returning ache are reasons to call. An implant site is sore for a few days after surgery and needs soft food and gentle cleaning while it heals. Either way, regular check-ups with a dentist in Australia keep an eye on it.
What to ask before you decide
- Can this tooth be saved, and how good is the outlook, in plain words?
- Is the root cracked? Can you show me on the X-ray or scan?
- Is there enough tooth left above the gum for a crown, or will I need a post?
- If the root canal fails later, what would we do then?
- If you recommend an implant, why can the tooth not be kept?
- How many trips will each option need, and how long between them?
- What is the full price of each option, including the extraction, any graft and the crown?
Common beliefs that are not quite right
- "An implant lasts longer than a root-filled tooth." In the comparisons, survival was about the same (Iqbal and Kim 2007; Borda 2025).
- "An implant is maintenance-free because it cannot decay." Implants needed more follow-up treatment than root-filled teeth in two direct comparisons (Doyle 2006; Hannahan and Eleazer 2008).
- "A tooth with a failed root canal must come out." Many can be saved by retreatment or root-end surgery (Ng 2008).
- "Root canals are very painful." The treatment is done under local anaesthetic. Patient-reported pain was comparable for the two options (Borda 2025).
- "You can always save a tooth." A split root, decay deep below the gum or severe bone loss means the tooth cannot be kept, and an implant is then a sound plan.
How does The Hudson help?
The Hudson plans and coordinates dental trips to Vietnam for people from Australia, New Zealand and the UK. We are not a clinic, and we do not decide whether your tooth is saved. The treating dentist at the partner clinic does that, from the exam, the X-ray and the scan.
We send your X-rays and history to the clinic before you fly, and we ask the dentist for both options with their prices when a tooth could go either way. Someone from The Hudson sits beside you at every appointment and makes sure you hear why a tooth is kept or taken out before anything is done.
How we make money
You don't pay us anything. When you go ahead with treatment, the clinic pays us a referral fee for each patient. It doesn't change your price: you pay the clinic's normal price, the same as if you walked in yourself.
Quick answers
Is it better to save a tooth or get an implant?
When the tooth can be properly treated, saving it is usually the first choice. Survival is about the same, and root-filled teeth needed fewer follow-up treatments than implants in direct comparisons. An implant is the right plan when the tooth cannot be kept.
How long does a root canal tooth last compared with an implant?
In a review of 55 implant studies and 13 root-filled tooth studies, survival did not differ significantly at any follow-up period (Iqbal and Kim 2007). Both last many years with a good crown and regular check-ups.
When is a tooth not worth saving?
When the root is split, the decay runs deep below the gum, or gum disease has left the tooth very loose with little bone. The dentist should show you why on the X-ray or scan.
Should I pull a tooth with a failed root canal?
Not always. Retreatment healed about 77% of teeth in a review of 17 studies (Ng 2008), and root-end surgery is another option. If the root is sound, saving it is often worth trying first.
Can I get the implant on the same trip as the extraction?
Sometimes the implant goes in on the day the tooth comes out, if the bone allows. The final crown still waits for the bone to heal, so implants in Vietnam take two trips, 3 to 6 months apart.
Not sure whether your tooth can be saved?
Send us an X-ray of the tooth, or your 3D scan. We will ask the dentist at our partner clinic whether it can be kept, and send you both options with prices. Free.
Ask about my toothSources
- Torabinejad M et al. Outcomes of root canal treatment and restoration, implant-supported single crowns, fixed partial dentures, and extraction without replacement: a systematic review. J Prosthet Dent, 2007.
- Iqbal MK, Kim S. For teeth requiring endodontic treatment, what are the differences in outcomes of restored endodontically treated teeth compared to implant-supported restorations? Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 2007.
- Doyle SL et al. Retrospective cross sectional comparison of initial nonsurgical endodontic treatment and single-tooth implants. J Endod, 2006.
- Hannahan JP, Eleazer PD. Comparison of success of implants versus endodontically treated teeth. J Endod, 2008.
- Sinsareekul C et al. Survival, complications, and patient-reported outcomes of endodontically treated teeth versus dental implant-supported prostheses: a systematic review. J Prosthet Dent, 2025.
- Borda MF et al. Comparative outcomes of endodontically treated teeth versus dental implant-supported prostheses: a systematic review. Acta Odontol Scand, 2025.
- Levin L, Halperin-Sternfeld M. Tooth preservation or implant placement: a systematic review of long-term tooth and implant survival rates. J Am Dent Assoc, 2013.
- Ng YL et al. Outcome of secondary root canal treatment: a systematic review of the literature. Int Endod J, 2008.
- Kim SG, Solomon C. Cost-effectiveness of endodontic molar retreatment compared with fixed partial dentures and single-tooth implant alternatives. J Endod, 2011.
- Setzer FC, Kim S. Comparison of long-term survival of implants and endodontically treated teeth. J Dent Res, 2014.
- The Hudson price list, November 2026 (partner clinics in Vietnam).
- Australian root canal prices by tooth: Compare Dentists, root canal cost in Australia (2026).
- Australian crown prices (A$1,250 to A$2,100): Choice, Dental fees, ADA Dental Fees Survey 2022.
- Australian single implant fees: Compare Dentists, dental procedure costs, from the Australian Dental Association fee survey (updated 11 June 2026).