Two dentists gave me two different plans. Which one is right?
Often both are reasonable, and the difference is judgement, not a mistake. Dentists disagree a lot, even on the same teeth: when 27 dental teachers planned the same three gum disease cases, they gave 6 to 19 different plans per case (Lanning 2005). Compare the two plans in three steps. First the diagnosis: do both dentists see the same problems in the same teeth? Then what each plan removes or keeps, because a pulled tooth or a ground-down tooth cannot be undone. Then the cost over 10 to 20 years, not just this year. When the plans still differ, the one that keeps more of your own teeth, with a clear reason for every tooth it treats, is usually the safer place to start.
Why two plans differ, at a glance
A treatment plan is a list of what a dentist thinks your mouth needs, tooth by tooth, and in what order. Two plans can differ for good reasons and for poor ones. Working out which is the first step.
| Reason | What it looks like | How to check |
|---|---|---|
| Different information | One dentist had a 3D scan or close-up X-rays; the other had only an OPG | Ask each what images the plan is based on |
| Different reading of the same tooth | One calls a tooth savable, the other calls it hopeless | Ask each to point to the problem on the X-ray and explain the reason |
| Different style | One treats early decay now, the other watches it | Ask what happens if you wait and recheck in 6 or 12 months |
| Different goals | One plan fixes what is broken, the other also improves the look | Split each plan into must-do and optional |
| Different budgets in mind | One plan is staged over years, the other does it all now | Ask for the same plan in stages |
| Different interests | A plan that does much more than needed, with little explanation | Ask for a reason for each tooth in writing |
Dentists disagree more than people think
It feels as if one plan must be right and the other wrong. The research shows that disagreement between dentists is normal, even on the same patient. A review of the research on dentists' decisions found variation everywhere it looked, in diagnoses, in the treatment chosen for single teeth, and in the number and cost of procedures suggested for the same patient (Bader 1995). It found this even when differences between patients were taken into account.
| Study | What was compared | What it found |
|---|---|---|
| Lanning 2005 | 27 dental teachers planning the same three gum disease cases | 6 to 19 different treatment plans per case; diagnoses for one patient ranged from gingivitis to aggressive gum disease |
| Heaven 2013 | Dentists in a large US practice network answering the same case scenarios | Agreement on when to fill decay was 40 to 68%; on whether to repair or replace an old filling, 36 to 43% |
| Espelid 1985 | A survey of 741 dentists in Norway | Two thirds would fill decay that was still only in the enamel; the rest would wait until it reached the inner tooth |
| Rytömaa 1979 | 12 dental teachers examining the same 10 people | Great variation in the plans for fillings and repairs |
| Dagassan-Berndt 2016 | Six implant dentists planning 59 implant sites from an OPG and from a 3D scan | Plans for adding bone matched between the two images in 55 to 72% of cases |
Two lessons follow. A different second plan does not mean the first dentist is dishonest. And a second plan that agrees with the first is worth a lot, because agreement is less common than it seems.
Step 1: compare the diagnosis, not the price
Most people compare the totals first. Start with the diagnosis instead: what each dentist thinks is wrong with each tooth. If the two dentists see different problems, the plans will differ, and no price comparison will help.
- Ask each dentist for the plan in writing, tooth by tooth, with the tooth number and the problem they found.
- Make a simple table: tooth number, what dentist A found, what dentist B found.
- Mark the teeth where they agree. These are usually the clear problems: a broken tooth, a large cavity, an abscess.
- List the teeth where they disagree. That short list is where your decision really lies.
- For each disputed tooth, ask both dentists what they saw and on which image.
Different images often explain different diagnoses. A flat OPG misses many small infections at root tips and small decay between teeth, which close-up X-rays and 3D scans show better. In one study, implant dentists' plans for the same sites differed depending on whether they used an OPG or a 3D scan, and the authors noted that reading the images depended mainly on the person reading them (Dagassan-Berndt 2016). If one plan was made from better images, give its diagnosis more weight.
Step 2: what each plan removes, and what it keeps
Next, look at what each plan does to your own teeth. Some treatments can be redone or reversed. Others cannot. The difference matters more than the price.
| Treatment | Can it be undone? | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Watching a tooth and rechecking | Yes | Nothing is lost if you wait and the problem does not grow |
| A filling or bonding | Mostly | Some tooth is removed, but little; it can be redone |
| A root canal | Partly | The nerve is removed but the tooth stays |
| A crown or veneer | No | Tooth is ground down for good; the tooth will always need a cover |
| Taking a tooth out | No | The tooth is gone, and the bone in the gap shrinks over time |
| Taking out all the teeth in a jaw for a full arch | No | Every tooth and the bone they hold are changed for good |
When one plan takes out or grinds down teeth that the other plan keeps, ask the first dentist why each of those teeth cannot be kept. A good answer names the problem in that tooth: a crack into the root, very little bone left, a root that has failed treatment before. A vague answer, such as "it is easier to do them all", is a reason to slow down.
Hudson, who founded The Hudson, has watched this happen in a clinic. A young man arrived having agreed online, before any scan, to a full-mouth plan. When the doctor examined him in person, he said plainly that some of the teeth could be saved as anchors and the case could be done for less. The lesson Hudson took from it is the rule The Hudson works by: the least treatment that solves the problem.
Step 3: the cost over 10 to 20 years
A plan that costs less today can cost more later, and the other way round. Compare what each plan is likely to need over the next 10 or 20 years: repairs, replacements, and the treatment a lost tooth will need later.
Take one badly broken back tooth. Plan A saves it with a root canal and a crown. Plan B takes it out and places an implant. A review that pooled 55 studies of single implants and 13 studies of root-treated, crowned teeth found no significant difference in how long they survived (Iqbal 2007). The authors concluded that the choice has to rest on other things, such as how much sound tooth is left, the bone, and cost.
| Plan | Price | How it is worked out |
|---|---|---|
| A: root canal and crown | A$389 to A$1,249 | Root canal A$167, plus a crown from A$222 to A$971; the top of the range adds a post and core at A$111 |
| B: extraction and implant | A$786 to A$3,102 or more | One complete implant tooth (implant, connector and crown), lowest to highest brand on our list; a bone graft can add to it |
Here plan A is lower in price and keeps your own tooth. Plan B can still be the right call if the root is cracked or there is too little tooth left to hold a crown. The point is to compare both plans on the same tooth, with the reason written down. Updated Nov 2026.
- Ask each dentist what is likely to need redoing in 10 years under their plan.
- Ask what a lost tooth would need later: an implant, a bridge, or nothing.
- Ask whether the plan can be done in stages, urgent teeth first.
- Check the brand and material for every crown and implant, so the two prices are for the same thing.
Step 4: who does the work, and what is in writing
Two plans on paper can hide two very different jobs. Before you compare prices, make sure each plan names the same things.
- The name of the dentist who will do each step, not just the clinic.
- The brand and type of every implant, and the material and brand of every crown.
- What is included: the 3D scan, temporary teeth, follow-up visits, any graft.
- The number of visits or trips and how long each takes.
- What happens, and who pays, if something fails in the first years.
A plan that leaves these out is not lower in price, just less clear. Ask for the missing parts before deciding.
Signs a plan deserves more trust
| A plan you can trust more | A plan to question |
|---|---|
| A reason for each tooth, linked to an X-ray or scan | One price for everything with no tooth-by-tooth list |
| Says which teeth can wait and which cannot | Says everything must be done now |
| Explains the other options and why it chose this one | Gives only one option |
| Keeps teeth where the reason to remove them is weak | Removes healthy-looking teeth "to keep it simple" |
| Names the brand, material and dentist | Says only "implant" or "zirconia" with no brand |
| Was made after a full exam and the right images | Was made from photos or a phone call alone |
Which plan to lean towards
| Your situation | Usual choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Both plans agree on the problems, differ on method | Either can work; choose on reasons, cost over years and the dentist | The diagnosis is settled; the rest is judgement |
| One plan keeps teeth the other removes | Start with the plan that keeps them, unless there is a clear reason they will fail | Removing a tooth cannot be undone; a kept tooth can still be removed later |
| One plan was made from a 3D scan, the other from an OPG | Give more weight to the 3D-scan plan for implants and bone | The OPG cannot show bone width |
| The plans differ on early decay only | Ask about watching it with a recheck | Dentists differ widely on when to fill early decay (Espelid 1985; Heaven 2013) |
| The plans differ on whether you need a full arch | Get a third look, tooth by tooth, before any extraction | It is the largest decision that cannot be reversed |
| One plan is much more expensive with little explanation | Ask for reasons in writing before going further | Every tooth treated should have a reason |
What this means if one plan is from Australia and one is from Vietnam
Many people have a plan from their dentist at home and a draft plan from a clinic in Vietnam. They can differ for all the reasons above, and for one more: the draft from Vietnam is usually made from your X-rays before anyone has examined you in person.
- Send the clinic in Vietnam your Australian plan as well as your X-rays. Ask the dentist to comment on each tooth where the plans differ.
- Expect the Vietnam plan to change after the exam and 3D scan on day one. Any change should come with a new written plan and price before treatment starts.
- Ask your dentist at home what they would do with the teeth the Vietnam plan treats differently.
- Keep both plans. They are useful if you need care at home later.
Questions to ask each dentist
- What did you find in each tooth you want to treat, and can you show me on the X-ray?
- Which teeth are urgent, and which could wait or be watched?
- For each tooth you want to remove or crown, why can it not be kept or filled?
- What would you do if this were your own mouth, and on a smaller budget?
- What is this plan likely to need in repairs or replacements over 10 years?
- Who exactly will do each step, and which brands and materials are in the price?
Common beliefs that are not quite right
- "If two dentists disagree, one is wrong." Disagreement is common even on the same teeth (Bader 1995; Lanning 2005). Both plans can be reasonable.
- "The bigger plan is the more thorough one." More treatment is not better treatment. Each tooth treated needs its own reason.
- "The lower-priced plan is cutting corners." It may simply keep more of your teeth. Compare what each plan removes before you compare prices.
- "An implant is always better than saving the tooth." Root-treated, crowned teeth and single implants survived about as well in a large review (Iqbal 2007).
- "A third opinion will only confuse me." For a full arch or several extractions, a third look at the disputed teeth is often worth it.
How does The Hudson help?
The Hudson plans and coordinates dental trips to Vietnam for people from Australia, New Zealand and the UK. We are not a clinic, and we do not diagnose or choose your treatment. The treating dentist at the partner clinic does that.
Send us the plans you already have with your X-rays. We ask the dentist at our partner clinic to answer tooth by tooth where the plans differ, and to say which teeth can be kept. Someone from The Hudson sits beside you at every appointment, so the reasons are explained to you before anything is done.
How we make money
You don't pay us anything. When you go ahead with treatment, the clinic pays us a referral fee for each patient. It doesn't change your price: you pay the clinic's normal price, the same as if you walked in yourself.
Quick answers
Is it normal for dentists to give different treatment plans?
Yes. In one study, 27 dental teachers gave 6 to 19 different plans for each of the same three cases (Lanning 2005). A review found variation in dentists' decisions everywhere it looked (Bader 1995).
Should I go with the lower-priced plan?
Not on price alone. Compare the diagnosis first, then what each plan removes or keeps, then the cost over 10 to 20 years. A lower-priced plan that keeps your teeth is often a sound start.
One dentist wants to pull my teeth and the other wants to save them. What now?
Ask the first dentist for the reason each tooth cannot be kept, shown on the X-ray. Removing a tooth cannot be undone, while a saved tooth can still be removed later if it fails.
How do I get a second opinion on a dental plan?
Ask for your X-rays and the written plan, tooth by tooth. Send both to another dentist and ask them to comment on each tooth, not just give a new total.
Why did my plan change after the dentist saw me in person?
A plan made from X-rays alone is a draft. The exam and a 3D scan show things an OPG cannot, such as bone width and small infections. A change should come with a new written plan and price.
Have two plans that do not match?
Send us both plans and your X-rays. We will ask the dentist at our partner clinic to go through each tooth where they differ and explain which teeth can be kept, in writing. Free.
Compare my plansSources
- Bader JD, Shugars DA. Variation in dentists' clinical decisions. J Public Health Dent, 1995.
- Lanning SK, Pelok SD et al. Variation in periodontal diagnosis and treatment planning among clinical instructors. J Dent Educ, 2005.
- Heaven TJ, Gordan VV et al. Agreement among dentists' restorative treatment planning thresholds for primary occlusal caries, primary proximal caries, and existing restorations: findings from The National Dental Practice-Based Research Network. J Dent, 2013.
- Espelid I, Tveit A. Variation in radiographic interpretation and restorative treatment decisions on approximal caries among dentists in Norway. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol, 1985.
- Rytömaa I, Järvinen V et al. Variation in caries recording and restorative treatment plan among university teachers. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol, 1979.
- Dagassan-Berndt DC, Zitzmann NU et al. Implant treatment planning regarding augmentation procedures: panoramic radiographs vs. cone beam computed tomography images. Clin Oral Implants Res, 2016.
- Iqbal MK, Kim S. For teeth requiring endodontic treatment, what are the differences in outcomes of restored endodontically treated teeth compared to implant-supported restorations? Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants, 2007.
- The Hudson price list, November 2026 (partner clinics in Vietnam).